Skip to content

Compare Bank & Credit Union Rates

Best savings rates in Amherst, NY

Compare published savings yields, money market accounts included, with minimums, requirements, collection dates and original sources.

Location

Top savings rates

Showing 1–15 results in Erie County, NY · Showing Erie County, NY: too few institutions in Amherst, NY

  1. HSBC USAPremier Relationship SavingsSavings · $1 min

    Bank · 1 branch

    4.40%APY$440 a year on $10,000with conditions
  2. Northwest BankPerformance Savings AccountSavings · $1 min

    Bank · 16 branches

    4.00%APY$400 a year on $10,000
  3. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 98
    SJP Federal Credit UnionMoney Market AccountMoney Market Account · $500 min

    Credit union · 1 branch

    3.56%APY$356 a year on $10,000
  4. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 94
    MOOG Employees FCUPlatinum Money Market SharesPlatinum Money Market Shares · $10,000 min

    Credit union · 1 branch

    3.40%APY$340 a year on $10,000
  5. HSBC USAPremier Relationship SavingsSavings · $1 min

    Bank · 1 branch

    3.10%APY$310 a year on $10,000with conditions
  6. Five Star BankHigh Yield Money Market AccountHigh Yield Money Market Account · $10,000 min · 0.10%–3.25% by balance

    Bank · 6 branches

    2.75%APY$275 a year on $10,000
  7. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 93
    Buffalo Conrail Federal Credit UnionMoney Market AccountMoney Market Account · $2,500 min · 1.76%–2.77% by balance

    Credit union · 1 branch

    2.26%APY$226 a year on $10,000
  8. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 89
    Ukrainian Federal Credit UnionMoney MarketMoney Market · $500 min · 0.10%–3.30% by balance

    Credit union · 2 branches

    2.02%APY$202 a year on $10,000
  9. Kaleida Health Federal Credit UnionMoney Market AccountMoney Market Account · $2,500 min · 1.50%–2.50% by balance

    Credit union · 3 branches

    2.00%APY$200 a year on $10,000
  10. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 89
    Cornerstone Community Federal Credit UnionCommunity SavingsSavings · $1,000 min

    Credit union · 1 branch

    2.00%APY$200 a year on $10,000
  11. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 87
    Boulevard Federal Credit UnionMoney MarketMoney Market · $1,000 min · 1.65%–2.15% by balance

    Credit union · 1 branch

    1.65%APY$165 a year on $10,000
  12. Top Carrot, Carrot Score 87
    Kenmore Teachers FCUShare AccountSavings

    Credit union · 1 branch

    1.50%APY$150 a year on $10,000
  13. SNIFCUMoney MarketMoney Market · $2,500 min · 1.50%–2.00% by balance

    Credit union · 1 branch

    1.50%APY$150 a year on $10,000
  14. CrossRoads Community Federal Credit UnionMoney Market Share Savings AccountMoney Market Share Savings Account · $2,500 min · 1.35%–1.55% by balance

    Credit union · 1 branch

    1.45%APY$145 a year on $10,000
  15. Bank of HollandAdvantage SavingsSavings · $0 min · 0.35%–1.25% by balance

    Bank · 3 branches

    1.25%APY$125 a year on $10,000with conditions

Carrot Score rates each institution on all its CD, savings, auto loan and credit card rates, not just the account shown. How we rank

What savings accounts pay in Erie County, NY

99 accounts at 47 banks and credit unions · checked Oct 6–22

Typical
0.20%
Top 10% from
1.72%
Banks, typical
0.05%
Credit unions, typical
0.33%

Is your bank paying you enough?

Find your bank or credit union to see all its rates and how they compare near you.

Suggestions appear after two characters. Use arrow keys and Enter to choose an institution, or submit to see all matches.

Buffalo, NY metro

Top Carrot institutions

Ranked across their CDs, savings, auto loans and credit cards. How scores work

  1. Ontario Shores FCUCredit union · 4 branches
  2. SJP Federal Credit UnionCredit union · 1 branch
  3. Niagara's ChoiceCredit union · 5 branches
See all ranked institutions