Skip to content

Compare Bank & Credit Union Rates

Top-rated banks and credit unions

Ranked by Carrot Score: how each one’s CD, savings, auto loan and credit card rates compare with every U.S. bank and credit union.

Location
Rank in
Suggestions appear after two characters. Use arrow keys and Enter to choose an institution, or submit to see all matches.

Top-rated in New York, NY-NJ metro

Showing 51–75 of 161 scored

  1. Merck Employees Federal Credit UnionCDs 89 · Savings 85 · Auto 68

    Credit union · 2 branches

    86Carrot Score#51 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  2. NCPD Federal Credit UnionSavings 88 · Auto 85 · Cards 83

    Credit union · 1 branch

    86Carrot Score#51 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  3. Liberty Savings Federal Credit UnionCDs 85 · Savings 87 · Auto 72 · Cards 77

    Credit union · 4 branches

    86Carrot Score#53 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  4. Raritan Bay Federal Credit UnionCDs 63 · Savings 88 · Auto 83 · Cards 77

    Credit union · 1 branch

    85Carrot Score#54 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  5. Westchester Schools FCUSavings 80 · Auto 99 · Cards 73

    Credit union · 1 branch

    85Carrot Score#55 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  6. Carver Federal Savings BankCDs 77 · Savings 96

    Bank · 7 branches

    85Carrot Score#56 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  7. Greater Metro Federal Credit UnionCDs 93 · Savings 64 · Auto 78 · Cards 81

    Credit union · 2 branches

    84Carrot Score#57 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  8. Manasquan BankCDs 80 · Savings 89

    Bank · 15 branches

    84Carrot Score#58 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  9. Freedom BankCDs 82 · Savings 89

    Bank · 5 branches

    84Carrot Score#59 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  10. BankwellCDs 77 · Savings 89

    Bank · 1 branch

    84Carrot Score#60 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  11. Selfreliance Federal Credit UnionCDs 85 · Savings 83 · Auto 81 · Cards 84

    Credit union · 3 branches

    84Carrot Score#60 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  12. United Teletech FinancialCDs 80 · Savings 89 · Auto 79

    Credit union · 6 branches

    84Carrot Score#62 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  13. Haven Savings BankCDs 87 · Savings 86

    Bank · 9 branches

    83Carrot Score#63 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  14. Teachers Federal Credit UnionCDs 86 · Savings 77 · Auto 83

    Credit union · 31 branches

    83Carrot Score#64 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  15. Unity BankCDs 92 · Savings 80 · Auto 60

    Bank · 18 branches

    83Carrot Score#64 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  16. The First Bank of GreenwichCDs 73 · Savings 96

    Bank · 1 branch

    83Carrot Score#66 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  17. I AM Federal Credit UnionCDs 87 · Savings 71 · Auto 82

    Credit union · 1 branch

    83Carrot Score#67 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  18. PSFCUCDs 70 · Savings 60 · Auto 93 · Cards 60

    Credit union · 13 branches

    82Carrot Score#68 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  19. GSL Savings BankCDs 76 · Savings 93

    Bank · 2 branches

    82Carrot Score#69 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  20. Popular BankCDs 86 · Savings 84

    Bank · 24 branches

    82Carrot Score#70 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  21. XCEL Federal Credit UnionCDs 86 · Savings 83 · Auto 77

    Credit union · 2 branches

    82Carrot Score#71 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  22. Island Federal Credit UnionCDs 81 · Savings 65 · Auto 83 · Cards 75

    Credit union · 8 branches

    81Carrot Score#72 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  23. Advantage Financial Federal Credit UnionCDs 65 · Savings 63 · Auto 89 · Cards 75

    Credit union · 1 branch

    81Carrot Score#73 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  24. Empire State BankCDs 88 · Savings 81

    Bank · 5 branches

    80Carrot Score#74 in New York, NY-NJ metro
  25. Magyar Bank (New Brunswick, NJ)CDs 88 · Savings 80

    Bank · 7 branches

    80Carrot Score#74 in New York, NY-NJ metro

Ranked by Carrot Score: how each institution’s CD, savings, auto loan and credit card rates compare with every U.S. bank and credit union. Scores run from 60 to 99; 90 and up means rates near the best in the country. Top Carrot marks a score of 87 or more, the top quarter of U.S. banks and credit unions. 167 of the 328 institutions with a branch in New York, NY-NJ metro have too few rates published or captured to score. Rankings are a preview, not awards.