Compare Bank & Credit Union Rates
Best savings rates in Garden City, NY
Compare published savings yields, money market accounts included, with minimums, requirements, collection dates and original sources.
Top savings rates
Showing 1–15 results in Garden City, NY
- 4.00%APY$400 a year on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: Personal accounts only. $5 monthly maintenance charge waived with at least a $300 average daily collected balance, or by maintaining a Flagstar personal checking relationship, or if the primary account owner is 24 years of age or younger.
Offer: Standard non-promotional rate applies to balances under $10,000 ($0.01 or greater). $5 monthly maintenance fee waived if average daily collected balance is at least $300, or with an owner relationship on a Flagstar personal checking account with a balance of at least $0.01, or if primary account owner is 24 or younger.
Promotional rate · $5 monthly fee · Effective Oct 17, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Flagstar Ready Savings Balance APY Up to $10,000 0.05% $10,000 and upYour amountMust be a new personal savings client and deposit new money. $1 minimum opening deposit. Reverts to standard non-promotional rate after 180 days. Early account closure fee may apply if closed within 180 days. 4.00% Rate checked
More details - 3.00%APY$300 a year on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: Available nationwide. Open your account with a deposit of $2,500 or more. Variable rate account. Rate matching available for advertised annual percentage yield (APY) and product of FDIC-insured competitor with retail locations in NY, NJ, and/or Palm Beach County, FL up to 90 days, up to a maximum of 4.50% APY.
Offer: Tier I. Variable rate account.
Promotional rate · 0.00% interest rate · No monthly fee · Effective Sep 1, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Connection Plus Savings Balance APY Up to $2,500 0.00% $2,500 – $250,000Your amountTier II. 3.00% $250,000 and upTier III. 3.10% Rate checked
More details - 3.00%APY$300 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Available in select markets/states to applicants with qualifying residential address. Monthly service fee is waived for accounts with a linked Citi checking account, an average monthly balance of $500 or more, or enrollment in Citi Priority, Citigold, or Citigold Private Client relationship tiers. Accounts with a zero balance for 90 calendar days are subject to closure.
Offer: Everyday Benefits tier. Rates apply to ZIP 57108 (OUT pricing region). $4.50 monthly fee waived with $500+ average monthly balance or linked Citi checking account.
2.96% interest rate · $4.50 monthly fee
Rate checked
More details - ConnectOne BankConnect Money MarketConnect Money Market · $1,000 min · 2.00%–2.10% by balance
Bank · 1 branch
2.00%APY$200 a year on $10,000Requirements
Product: Avoid the $10 monthly minimum balance fee by maintaining an average daily balance of $5,000 or more.
Offer: Avoid $10 monthly fee with $5,000+ average daily balance.
1.98% interest rate · $10 monthly fee · Effective Sep 1, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Connect Money Market Balance APY Up to $25,000Your amount 2.00% $25,000 and up 2.10% Rate checked
More details - 1.61%APY$161 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Dividends compounded quarterly. Federally insured by NCUA.
Offer: Dividends compounded quarterly; no fees.
1.60% interest rate · Compounded quarterly · No monthly fee
Rate checked
More details - OceanFirst BankFirstWave Money MarketFirstWave Money Market · $0 min · 0.05%–2.50% by balance
Bank · 1 branch
1.25%APY$125 a year on $10,000intro rateRequirements
Product: New money only. $10,000 minimum to receive promotional rates. Available for consumer and business.
Promotional rate · 0.05% interest rate · Effective Dec 15, 2025
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for FirstWave Money Market Balance APY Up to $10,000 0.05% $10,000 – $100,000Your amountNew money only; 1.25% $100,000 – $250,000New money only; 2.00% $250,000 – $500,000New money only; 2.25% $500,000 and upNew money only; 2.50% Rate checked
More details - 0.12%APY$12 a year on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Available in select markets/regions. Monthly service fee is waived with a linked Citi checking account, an average monthly balance of $500 or more, or enrollment in Citi Priority, Citigold, or Citigold Private Client relationship tiers. Accounts with a zero balance for 90 calendar days are subject to closure.
Offer: Citigold Private Client relationship tier (requires $800,000 CAMB in Eligible Deposit and Investment accounts). Rates apply to ZIP 57108 (OUT pricing region). Monthly fee waived for Citigold Private Client tier.
Qualified rate · 0.12% interest rate · $4.50 monthly fee
Rate checked
More details - 0.10%APY$10 a year on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Monthly fee of $15 waived by maintaining a minimum daily balance of $10,000 or linking an eligible TD Beyond or TD Complete checking account. Standard and Rate Bump APY tiers available (Rate bump requires linking an eligible TD account).
Offer: Standard APY
Qualified rate · $15 monthly fee · Effective Oct 3, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for TD Signature Savings Balance APY Up to $10,000 0.01% $10,000 – $25,000Your amountRate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 0.10% $25,000 – $50,000Rate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 0.25% $50,000 – $100,000Rate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 0.50% $100,000 – $250,000Rate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 2.00% $250,000 – $500,000Rate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 2.50% $500,000 – $1,000,000Rate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 2.50% $1,000,000 and upRate Bump APY with linked eligible TD account 2.50% Rate checked
More details - 0.10%APY$10 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Personal accounts only. Initial minimum opening deposit to earn higher rate is $25,000. Account must be funded within 90 days of approval date. Early closure fee may apply if closed within 180 days. $15 monthly service charge waived with at least a $10,000 average daily collected balance or with a Flagstar personal checking relationship.
Offer: Tier 1 balance rate. $15 monthly maintenance fee waived if average daily collected balance is at least $10,000 or if owner of a Flagstar personal checking account with balance of at least $0.01.
$15 monthly fee
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Flagstar Performance Savings Balance APY Up to $10,000 0.10% $10,000 – $25,000Your amountTier 2 balance rate. 0.10% $25,000 – $50,000Tier 3 balance rate. 3.20% $50,000 – $100,000Tier 4 balance rate. $15 monthly maintenance fee waived if average daily collected balance is at least $10,000 or with personal checking relationship. 3.20% $100,000 – $500,000Tier 5 balance rate. $15 monthly maintenance fee waived if average daily collected balance is at least $10,000 or with personal checking relationship. 3.20% $500,000 and upTier 6 balance rate. $15 monthly maintenance fee waived if average daily collected balance is at least $10,000 or with personal checking relationship. 3.20% Rate checked
More details - 0.09%APY$9 a year on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Available in select markets/regions. Monthly service fee is waived with a linked Citi checking account, an average monthly balance of $500 or more, or enrollment in Citi Priority, Citigold, or Citigold Private Client relationship tiers. Accounts with a zero balance for 90 calendar days are subject to closure.
Offer: Citigold relationship tier (requires $180,000 CAMB in Eligible Deposit and Investment accounts). Rates apply to ZIP 57108 (OUT pricing region). Monthly fee waived for Citigold tier.
Qualified rate · 0.09% interest rate · $4.50 monthly fee
Rate checked
More details - 0.06%APY$6 a year on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Available in select markets/regions. Monthly service fee is waived with a linked Citi checking account, an average monthly balance of $500 or more, or enrollment in Citi Priority, Citigold, or Citigold Private Client relationship tiers. Accounts with a zero balance for 90 calendar days are subject to closure.
Offer: Citi Priority relationship tier (requires $30,000 CAMB in Eligible Deposit and Investment accounts). Rates apply to ZIP 57108 (OUT pricing region). Monthly fee waived for Citi Priority tier.
Qualified rate · 0.06% interest rate · $4.50 monthly fee
Rate checked
More details - 0.05%APY$5 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Must be 18 years or older.
Offer: Tier 1: 0.05% APY for daily balances of $0.01 - $4,999.99. Maintain an average daily balance of at least $10,000 to avoid the $25 monthly maintenance charge.
$25 monthly fee · Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Tiered Money Market Balance APY Up to $5,000 0.05% $5,000 – $25,000Your amount 0.05% $25,000 – $50,000 0.05% $50,000 – $100,000 0.05% $100,000 – $500,000 0.05% $500,000 – $1,500,000 0.10% $1,500,000 – $2,500,000 0.10% $2,500,000 – $5,000,000 0.10% $5,000,000 – $10,000,000 0.10% $10,000,000 and up 0.01% Rate checked
More details - 0.05%APY$5 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Must be 18 years or older with a U.S. residential address. Initial opening deposit cannot come from an existing Valley bank account.
Offer: Earn 0.05% APY on balances of $0.01 up to $10,000. Maintain an average daily balance of at least $10,000 to avoid the $25 monthly maintenance charge.
$25 monthly fee · Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 0.05%APY$5 a year on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Monthly fee of $15 waived by maintaining a minimum daily balance of $10,000 or linking an eligible TD Beyond or TD Complete checking account. Standard and Rate Bump APY tiers available (Rate bump requires linking an eligible TD account).
Offer: Standard APY
Qualified rate · $15 monthly fee · Effective Oct 3, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 0.04%APY$4 a year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Variable rate savings account. $8.00 monthly maintenance fee waived for the first 6 months for new accounts; thereafter waived by maintaining a minimum daily balance of $500 or more, owning a Bank of America Advantage Relationship Banking account, having an account owner under age 25, or being enrolled in BofA Rewards at Preferred Plus, Preferred Honors, or Premier tier. No Overdraft Item Fees. Paper check writing is not permitted. Online new account opening limit is $250,000.
Offer: Standard rate for balances less than $5,000. Variable rate. Applicable to Western North Carolina. $8.00 monthly fee with waiver options ($500 minimum daily balance, owner under 25, Advantage Relationship Banking, or qualifying BofA Rewards tier; fee waived first 6 months for new accounts).
0.04% interest rate · $8 monthly fee · Effective Oct 5, 2026
Rate checked
More details
Carrot Score rates each institution on all its CD, savings, auto loan and credit card rates, not just the account shown. How we rank
What savings accounts pay in Garden City, NY
30 accounts at 12 banks and credit unions · checked Oct 6–22
- Typical
- 0.04%
- Top 10% from
- 2.10%
- Banks, typical
- 0.03%
- Credit unions, typical
- 1.61%
Is your bank paying you enough?
Find your bank or credit union to see all its rates and how they compare near you.
New York, NY-NJ metro
Top Carrot institutions
Ranked across their CDs, savings, auto loans and credit cards. How scores work
- Quorum Federal Credit UnionCredit union · 1 branch
- BTG Pactual Bank, National AssociationBank · 1 branch
- USALLIANCE FinancialCredit union · 3 branches