Compare Bank & Credit Union Rates
Best CD rates in Garden City, NY
Compare published certificate yields with their terms, opening minimums, requirements, collection dates and original sources.
Top CD rates
Showing 1–15 results in Garden City, NY
- 4.30%APY$430 over 1 year on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: FDIC insured up to $250,000 per depositor. No monthly fees when held to maturity. Early withdrawal penalty applies. Maximum deposit is $10 million. Not available for public units.
Offer: Must present offer at account opening. Limited-time offer. Not available for public units or Business CDs. Certain restrictions, including area restrictions, may apply.
Promotional rate · Balance cap $10,000,000 · Effective Oct 16, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 4.25%APY$425 over 1 year on $10,000
4.16% interest rate
Rate checked
More details - 4.18%APY$312 over 9 months on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Limited-time offer for new deposit customers, loan-only customers, or employees of OceanFirst Bank. Requires new money not currently on deposit at OceanFirst Bank. Automatically renews for a 9-month term at published non-special rate. Penalty for early withdrawal may apply. Government accounts excluded.
Offer: Promotional APY increase and $250,000 maximum funding amount available if opening a non-interest FreeStyle Checking or Community Business Checking account within 60 days of certificate opening date (employees may open any OceanFirst checking account).
Qualified rate · 4.10% interest rate · Balance cap $250,000
Rate checked
More details - 4.10%APY$203 over 6 months on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: Limited-time promotional Certificate of Deposit. New money deposit only. APY is fixed for the 6-month term. Early withdrawal penalties may apply.
Offer: Limited-time promotional rate. New money deposit only. $500 minimum to open and to obtain the advertised APY.
Promotional rate · Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.85%APY$583 over 18 months on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Requires an eligible/qualifying M&T Bank checking account (such as MyChoice Premium Checking, M&T Select, M&T Select With Interest, Power Checking, or Advantage Checking). Maximum deposit is $1,000,000 per account ($750,000 if opened online). Minimum balance to obtain APY is $1.00. Early withdrawal penalties apply.
Offer: Requires a qualifying checking account. Maximum deposit is $1,000,000 ($750,000 if opened online). Minimum balance to obtain APY is $1.00.
Qualified rate · 3.78% interest rate · Balance cap $1,000,000 · Effective Jul 30, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.75%APY$123 over 4 months on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: ConnectOne Bank opens CDs as Time Deposits. IRA Time Deposits are not available online. Promotional rates subject to change without notice. Early withdrawal penalties may be imposed.
Offer: 4 Month Penalty-Free CD. No early withdrawal penalties imposed unless funds are withdrawn within 7 days of account opening (forfeits earned interest). Promotional rate.
Promotional rate · 3.68% interest rate · Effective Sep 1, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.75%APY$217 over 7 months on $10,000
Requirements
Product: At maturity, automatically renews into a 3 Month Flexible CD at a lower interest rate unless changed during 7-day grace period. Online opening limit is $250,000.
3.69% interest rate · Effective Oct 5, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Featured CD Balance APY Up to $9,999 3.75% $10,000 – $99,999Your amount 3.75% $100,000 – $999,999 4.11% $1,000,000 and up 4.11% Rate checked
More details - 3.75%APY$343 over 11 months on $10,000intro rate
Requirements
Product: Membership open to those who live, work, worship, volunteer, or go to school in Nassau and portions of Suffolk County, NY, and immediate family members. $5 deposit into a Share Savings Account required. A penalty may be charged for early withdrawal.
Offer: Standard rate without $5,0000 deposit in new money.
Promotional rate
Rate checked
More details - 3.55%APY$88 over 3 months on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Fixed-rate CD. APY is locked for the 3-month term. Additional deposits not allowed after opening. Early withdrawal penalties may apply. Adults over 18 are eligible. Fund up to $500,000 online and up to $1,000,000 in a branch.
Offer: $500 minimum opening balance and $500 minimum daily balance required to obtain the advertised APY.
Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.50%APY$173 over 6 months on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Fixed-rate CD. APY is locked for the 6-month term. Additional deposits not allowed after opening. Early withdrawal penalties may apply. Adults over 18 are eligible. Fund up to $500,000 online and up to $1,000,000 in a branch. Distinct from the limited-time 6-month promotional CD.
Offer: $500 minimum opening balance and $500 minimum daily balance required to obtain the advertised APY.
Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.50%APY$350 over 1 year on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Fixed-rate CD. APY is locked for the 12-month term. Additional deposits not allowed after opening. Early withdrawal penalties may apply. Adults over 18 are eligible. Fund up to $500,000 online and up to $1,000,000 in a branch.
Offer: $500 minimum opening balance and $500 minimum daily balance required to obtain the advertised APY.
Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.45%APY$522 over 18 months on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Fixed-rate CD. APY is locked for the 18-month term. Additional deposits not allowed after opening. Early withdrawal penalties may apply. Adults over 18 are eligible. Fund up to $500,000 online and up to $1,000,000 in a branch.
Offer: $500 minimum opening balance and $500 minimum daily balance required to obtain the advertised APY.
Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.30%APY$219 over 8 months on $10,000with conditions
Requirements
Product: Minimum deposit requirement of $1,000 to open a CD. Penalty for early withdrawal.
Offer: Requires linked qualifying Chase checking account.
Qualified rate · 3.25% interest rate · Effective Oct 16, 2026
Rate by balance
Rate by balance for Certificate of Deposit Balance APY Up to $9,999 3.30% $10,000 – $99,999Your amount 3.30% $100,000 and up 3.80% Rate checked
More details - Peapack Private Bank & TrustPersonal Certificates of Deposit (CDs)CD · 9 months · $500 min
Bank · 1 branch
3.25%APY$243 over 9 months on $10,000with conditionsRequirements
Offer: New money only. Interest paid monthly. 9 Month rolls into 182 day CD.
Qualified rate · 3.21% interest rate · Effective Oct 15, 2026
Rate checked
More details - 3.25%APY$661 over 24 months on $10,000
Requirements
Product: Fixed-rate CD. APY is locked for the 24-month term. Additional deposits not allowed after opening. Early withdrawal penalties may apply. Adults over 18 are eligible. Fund up to $500,000 online and up to $1,000,000 in a branch.
Offer: $500 minimum opening balance and $500 minimum daily balance required to obtain the advertised APY.
Effective Oct 22, 2026
Rate checked
More details
Carrot Score rates each institution on all its CD, savings, auto loan and credit card rates, not just the account shown. How we rank
What CDs pay in Garden City, NY
138 CDs at 10 banks and credit unions · checked Oct 4–22
- Typical
- 0.75%
- Top 10% from
- 3.75%
- Banks, typical
- 0.50%
- Credit unions, typical
- 2.50%
Is your bank paying you enough?
Find your bank or credit union to see all its rates and how they compare near you.
New York, NY-NJ metro
Top Carrot institutions
Ranked across their CDs, savings, auto loans and credit cards. How scores work
- Quorum Federal Credit UnionCredit union · 1 branch
- BTG Pactual Bank, National AssociationBank · 1 branch
- USALLIANCE FinancialCredit union · 3 branches